David de Gea 6
Could have done better on the second and third goals by his standards, and was not particularly authoritative on crosses. We needed a huge performance from the Spaniard tonight, but sadly we didn't get one.
Did well initially but increasingly let Franck Ribery get the better of him as the game wore on. Was not hugely troubled for an out-of-position defender.
Nemanja Vidic 7
Could have done better with letting Thomas Muller get away from him for his goal, but was otherwise very solid all evening.
Did well in defence as a surprise starter, but was utterly awful in possession, constantly surrendering possession with aimless hoofs to nobody.
Can't really be blamed for the Muller goal, as he was showing Robben onto his weaker foot. A superb goal, and some pieces of very good defending too.
A couple of poor giveaways, but was not given the chasing he might have been. Did nothing of any great importance.
Superb defensive work helped completely stymie the Bayern attack in the first half and beyond, and it was bizarre to see him taken off.
Poor final ball and decisions let him down, but he was industrious and calm in possession.
One of his better games for a while, defending well and being effective and brave while getting forwards too.
Just utterly, utterly, utterly awful. Rancid, insipid, woeful stuff. Inject him with something stronger next time. Had he had even an OK game we would have gone through.
Ought to have created at least one goal but for Rooney's shocking finish, was typically hardworking and played a large role in why United were able to match Bayern for most of the tie.