David de Gea 6
Could have done better on the second and third goals by his standards, and was not particularly authoritative on crosses. We needed a huge performance from the Spaniard tonight, but sadly we didn't get one.
Phil Jones 6
Did well initially but increasingly let Franck Ribery get the better of him as the game wore on. Was not hugely troubled for an out-of-position defender.
Nemanja Vidic 7
Could have done better with letting Thomas Muller get away from him for his goal, but was otherwise very solid all evening.
Chris Smalling 6
Did well in defence as a surprise starter, but was utterly awful in possession, constantly surrendering possession with aimless hoofs to nobody.
Patrice Evra 8
Can't really be blamed for the Muller goal, as he was showing Robben onto his weaker foot. A superb goal, and some pieces of very good defending too.
Michael Carrick 5
A couple of poor giveaways, but was not given the chasing he might have been. Did nothing of any great importance.
Darren Fletcher 8
Superb defensive work helped completely stymie the Bayern attack in the first half and beyond, and it was bizarre to see him taken off.
Shinji Kagawa 6
Poor final ball and decisions let him down, but he was industrious and calm in possession.
Antonio Valencia 8
One of his better games for a while, defending well and being effective and brave while getting forwards too.
Wayne Rooney 1
Just utterly, utterly, utterly awful. Rancid, insipid, woeful stuff. Inject him with something stronger next time. Had he had even an OK game we would have gone through.
Danny Welbeck 7
Ought to have created at least one goal but for Rooney's shocking finish, was typically hardworking and played a large role in why United were able to match Bayern for most of the tie.